RWR Proposal VOTE

We have on our hands a difficult decision to make.
IF they honour this proposal, then it could be worth it. I am always looking for peace over war, but this doesn't feel right. It feels like blackmail. It feels like it wouldn't be right to accept the offer, and that we should go about our ways without hiding from these exploiters.

"
01-02 05:56:42 Godfather918 [4:35:4] no subject
we were thinking, and we have a lil buissness deal for you, we are going for moon shots by our other planets out in the 8s, but we were thinking if you all (your alliance) would scavage up 1667 light fighters each time intell we get a moon then we will protect you from anyone else out here in the 8s for the rest of the game, and never attack you or your alliance again, but only when one of us gets a moon, and if the moonshot failed yall can get your DF and try again, what do you think? "

I want to know what everyone thinks about this. Please reply to this with your feedback and vote, either way.
Thank you.

i say we shouldn't do it
it sounds like a scam when we give them the moon they will harvest all the debris and we won't be able to do anything because a lot of our fleet would already be destroyed. You never know what they will do, cause you don't know if they will keep their end of the bargain.

Hi all
I say no to the idea of giving into this sort of thing, I would rather fight than be blackmailed into giving them a moon ,If they get me napping they could give me a moon with the fleet i have out here, so i say Nooo.
acorn

Wolfang votes: nay to the proposal of giving a moon to Godfather918 and alliance. Reasons for this have already been given in previous statements by fellow members.

Umm...this doesn't look like something I would want to wake up to every morning... No, sounds very fishy...

yell at me for always going against the flow but I looked at there group and they are about honor in the battle feild so mabey if we do this we can make allies with them and have them on our federation they are a strong group having 30 members and 18 or so in there wing group so they would be a valuable allie and a very annoying enemy It is a risk i agree but I think we should instead of asking for a nap with them have a alliance and ask them to join our federation with hold who is in the federation for security resions but say how many alliances there are and he might like the idea and since we did a big favor for him they will help us more in the future again I understand that they could just turn around and bite us in the ass pardon my french but I just thought i should say that